Jesus Didn’t Plead the Fifth

Then they said, “Why do we need any more testimony? We have heard it from his own lips.” – Luke 22:71

I think it’s good for us to sit with this verse for a bit. It might speak to us more than we realize.

Luke lets us see how quickly things move. Jesus is brought before the council, and from that moment forward – the outcome is basically sealed.

The religious leaders are no longer searching for a solution to the “Jesus” problem. They have everything they need. And not because the truth has become clear to them, but because they’ve finally decided what to do with Jesus.

That’s the turning point. It’s no longer about more investigating and continuing to build a case against Him. Now they can focus on having Jesus executed. And oh, how confident His accusers are! “We have heard it ourselves!” They think they’re standing on solid ground. But they couldn’t be more wrong. They heard His words, but they didn’t hear Him.

That still happens today.

We can read Scripture, hear sermons, and even repeat Jesus’ own words… and still decide ahead of time what we will do with Him. We can come to Him not with the intention of being changed, but rather to confirm what we already believe or what we want. Wasn’t this what the religious leaders were doing? Think about it. They weren’t lacking information. They were resisting Him and refusing to surrender.

But Jesus’ identity always presses for a response. In agreement or disagreement, in resistance or surrender. There’s never a neutral response. The Sanhedrin had heard enough to condemn Him. But those same words, received differently, are enough to save us!

So… What are we doing with what we’ve heard? Not what we know, or what we can explain. Because eventually, like them, we reach a point where we too say, “I’ve heard enough.” And at that moment, our heart is revealed in our response.

Jesus didn’t plead the fifth and neither can we. His own testimony convicted Him.

Does it convict us?